Collaborative Problem Solving for Explosive Kids: What Parents Should Know
Last reviewed: 11/03/2026
Reviewed by: Dr. Kiesa Kelly

The blowup comes at the same point almost every day. Homework, screens off, getting out the door. You have tried warnings, charts, taking things away, and staying calm, and the screaming still comes. Maybe someone has told you that you need to be firmer. Maybe someone else has told you that you need to be gentler. Neither has helped much.
Collaborative problem solving for explosive kids starts from a different question. Instead of asking how to make a child comply, it asks what is getting in the way, and then works that problem out with the child, ahead of time, instead of in the middle of a meltdown. It is not the only evidence-based option, and it is not a reason to skip a careful look at what is driving the behavior. ScienceWorks does not offer Collaborative & Proactive Solutions as a formal program. If you are weighing options, you can read about the specialized therapy approaches we do use, including parent management training.
In this article, you'll learn:
What collaborative problem solving is, and why two programs use similar names
The core idea behind it: lagging skills and unsolved problems
How a Plan B conversation works at home, step by step
What the randomized trials show, and how it compares with parent management training
When explosive behavior needs an evaluation or a safety plan first
What collaborative problem solving is: the short answer
Collaborative problem solving, in the version tested in the trials below (Collaborative & Proactive Solutions), is a psychosocial treatment model for behaviorally challenging young people [1]. It teaches parents to identify the skills a child is missing and the specific expectations the child is struggling to meet, then to solve those problems together with the child, before the next blowup rather than during it [2][3].
A note on names. A 2004 trial led by Dr. Ross Greene tested the approach under the name collaborative problem solving [4]. Dr. Greene co-authored the later trials and a 2019 review, in which the model is called Collaborative & Proactive Solutions (CPS) [1][5][6], and Lives in the Balance, where Dr. Greene is listed as the program contact [2], offers free resources on it, including an online tour for parents [3]. Think:Kids, a program in the Department of Psychiatry at Massachusetts General Hospital directed by Dr. Stuart Ablon, uses the name Collaborative Problem Solving [8]. The two share roots [4], but Lives in the Balance treats them as distinct models [7]. The U.S. and Australian trials described below tested Collaborative & Proactive Solutions; the Swedish trial tested a separate, modified model. In this article, "collaborative problem solving" in lowercase means the general approach; when we describe specific steps, tools, or trial results, we mean Dr. Greene's Collaborative & Proactive Solutions.
Three misconceptions tend to keep parents from taking a closer look.
"It's just letting kids off the hook." In reality, the adult's concern is a required part of every Plan B conversation, and the solution has to be realistic and acceptable to both the adult and the child [2]. The framework also names two other responses: Plan A, where the adult decides alone, and Plan C, where a problem is set aside for now, though its emphasis is on solving problems together rather than unilaterally [2][3]. Collaborative does not mean expectation-free.
"It's a nice philosophy, but it hasn't really been tested." In reality, two randomized trials of Collaborative & Proactive Solutions in children aged 7 to 14 with oppositional defiant disorder found it about as effective as parent management training, a well-established treatment [5][6]. Our post comparing family therapy and parent management training explains what that comparison treatment involves. That is a meaningful result, with limits we cover below.
"An explosive kid just wants control." In reality, the model's starting assumption, summed up in the title of one of its videos as "kids do well if they can," is that concerning behavior is not a matter of poor motivation [3]. That is a working assumption, not a test result, but it changes the question from "how do I win this?" to "what is hard here?" If demands themselves seem to set off panic rather than defiance, our parent's guide to demand avoidance covers a related pattern.
🧩 Key takeaway: Collaborative problem solving keeps adult expectations. What changes is when and how the problem gets solved: together, and ahead of time.
The core idea: kids do well if they can
The model asks parents to change their lens before they change their tactics [3]. Lives in the Balance, which publishes the model's parent materials, states its position plainly: concerning behavior "is not the result of poor parenting, faulty learning, or poor motivation" [3]. Instead, the explosion is treated as a signal that a demand is outrunning a skill.
Lagging skills, not lack of motivation
A lagging skill is a skill that is not yet strong enough for what the situation asks: shifting from one activity to another, tolerating frustration, handling a change in plans, or putting a feeling into words. The model uses a structured checklist, the Assessment of Skills and Unsolved Problems, to help adults name these skills [3]. The model's own materials note that naming the lagging skills tends to be the easier part for most adults [3].
Unsolved problems: finding the predictable triggers
Unsolved problems are the specific expectations a child is having difficulty meeting [3]. In our experience, it helps to word them as concrete situations, not as behaviors: "difficulty starting math homework after school," rather than "screams and throws pencils." The model's materials note that wording unsolved problems is often the harder part [3]. In our experience, it is also the step that turns a vague sense of "he explodes all the time" into a short list of predictable moments. Families then prioritize which problems to work on first, rather than tackling everything at once [2][3].
Consider a composite example. A nine-year-old melts down most weekdays at 4:15, when her mother reminds her about homework. On paper, the problem is defiance. Once her parents fill in the checklist, a pattern shows up: the blowups happen on days with long writing assignments, and almost never on math-only days. She is exhausted after school, and writing is slow and hard for her. The unsolved problem is not "refuses homework." It is "difficulty starting writing assignments after school," and that is a problem the family can actually work on.
🔍 Key takeaway: Explosions tend to cluster around a short list of predictable situations. Writing those situations down is often the first real progress.
How it works at home: a Plan B conversation, step by step
The model describes three ways adults can respond to an unsolved problem: Plan A, where the adult decides and imposes a solution; Plan B, where the adult and child solve it together; and Plan C, where the problem is set aside for now [2]. Plan B is the heart of the approach, and it happens proactively, at a calm time, not in the middle of an outburst [2][3].
Empathy: understanding the child's concern
The first step is gathering information from the child to get a clear understanding of their concern or perspective [2]. The adult names the unsolved problem neutrally and asks what is going on. In practice, this might sound like: "I've noticed that writing homework has been hard to start after school. What's up?" Then the adult listens, asks follow-up questions, and resists jumping to solutions. The goal of this step is to understand, not to agree.
Defining the adult concern
Next, the adult defines their own concern about the same unsolved problem [2]. This is where the "not permissive" part lives. A parent might say: "My concern is that if the writing doesn't get done, you'll fall behind and your teacher won't see what you can do."
The invitation: solving it together
Finally, the child and adult brainstorm solutions and settle on a plan that is both realistic and mutually satisfactory [2]. The adult might open this step with an invitation such as: "I wonder if there's a way we could make sure you get a break after school and the writing still gets started. Do you have any ideas?" If the first plan does not work, that is information, not failure, and the problem goes back on the table.
Here is how that might look with the nine-year-old above. Her concern turns out to be that she is wiped out after school and that writing feels endless. Her mother's concern is that the work gets done before bedtime. Together they try a 30-minute snack-and-play break, then writing in two short chunks, with her mother sitting nearby for the first five minutes. Some days still go badly. But the 4:15 battle now has a plan that both of them helped write. If writing stays unusually slow and hard even on good days, it is also worth asking the school or your pediatrician about an evaluation for a learning or attention difficulty.
Or consider a composite example with an older child. A twelve-year-old explodes when told to turn off his game for dinner. In a calm moment later, his father learns that the problem is not dinner. It is being stopped in the middle of a match he cannot pause, which means losing for his whole team. His father's concern is that the family eats together on weeknights. They agree on a ten-minute warning, a rule that he does not start a new match after the warning, and a later dinner on the one night his team plays. In the clinician-led version of the model, the clinician actively guides the first problem-solving conversations, with the goal of helping the child and parents solve problems together on their own [2].
💬 Key takeaway: A Plan B conversation has three parts: the child's concern, the adult's concern, and a solution that works for both. It happens before the next blowup, not during it.

What the research shows
The strongest evidence comes from two randomized trials. In a U.S. trial of 134 children aged 7 to 14 with oppositional defiant disorder, both Collaborative & Proactive Solutions and parent management training were better than a waitlist and did not differ from each other [5]. About half of the children in each treatment no longer met criteria for the diagnosis and were judged much or very much improved after treatment, compared with none on the waitlist, and the gains held six months later [5]. Younger age and having an anxiety disorder predicted better results with both treatments [5].
A second trial, in an Australian community setting, randomized 160 children aged 7 to 14 with oppositional defiant disorder to the two treatments for up to 16 weekly sessions [6]. Outcomes were similar: 45 to 50 percent of children were in the nonclinical range after treatment, 67 percent were rated much improved, and gains held at six months [6]. The authors concluded that the model offers "a viable choice for families who seek alternate treatments" [6]. An earlier, smaller 2004 study of 47 children reported results that were equivalent to, and in some areas better than, parent training [4].
It is worth being clear about the limits. Both large trials compared the model with another active treatment, and only the U.S. trial also included a waitlist group. The developer of the model was a co-author on all three studies [4][5][6]. A review written by the developer concludes that the model is at least equivalent to parent management training and "may hold additional benefits" for parent-child interactions and children's skills, which is a hypothesis, not a settled finding [1]. The UK's NICE guideline on conduct problems, first published in 2013, recommends parent training programs based on a social learning model for children aged 3 to 11, and group problem-solving programs for children aged 9 to 14; it does not name collaborative problem solving or Collaborative & Proactive Solutions [9].
📊 Key takeaway: In trials of children with oppositional defiant disorder, Collaborative & Proactive Solutions worked about as well as parent management training. It is an evidence-based option, not the only one.

Collaborative problem solving or parent management training?
Parent management training is the well-established treatment the trials used as their comparison [5][6], and the UK's NICE guideline recommends parent training programs built on a social learning model, using modeling, rehearsal, and feedback to improve parenting skills [9]. Our post comparing family therapy and parent management training, linked above, walks through what that approach involves. Since the two did similarly well in head-to-head trials [5][6], the choice often comes down to fit.
In our clinical experience, a practical way to think about it:
If rewards and consequences have helped in other areas and the main problem is consistency at home, parent management training may be the more natural place to start.
If consequences seem to make things worse, outbursts cluster around specific demands, and your child can talk about what is hard once calm, collaborative problem solving may fit better.
If you are not sure, or the outbursts are frequent or dangerous, start with an evaluation and let the treatment choice follow from what it finds.
Before you start with any therapist, it helps to ask a few concrete questions:
Which model do you use, and what training do you have in it?
Will my child be part of the sessions, or will you work mainly with us as parents?
How will we measure whether things are improving, and when would we change course?
What would you do if the outbursts become unsafe?
⚖️ Key takeaway: Both approaches have trial support. Choose based on what has and has not worked for your family, and on what an evaluation finds.
Who it fits, and when it is not enough
The two large trials enrolled children aged 7 to 14 with oppositional defiant disorder, and the model's clearinghouse listing describes it for children aged 4 to 14 [2][5][6]. Evidence for teenagers and for younger children is thinner, and the U.S. trial excluded autistic children [10]. A Swedish trial of a related, newer model, in which children and parents work out solutions together, included many children with autism or ADHD; after 10 weeks, 51.4 percent were much or very much improved, compared with 5.6 percent with usual care [10]. That model is not the same program, and the trial was short, but it is encouraging for neurodivergent children.
When explosive behavior needs an evaluation first
Frequent, intense outbursts are a symptom, not a diagnosis. Irritability is associated with several childhood conditions, including ADHD, oppositional defiant disorder, and anxiety disorders [11]. A newer diagnosis, disruptive mood dysregulation disorder, describes ongoing irritability and anger with frequent, intense temper outbursts that happen in multiple settings and affect daily life [11]. If your child is autistic or has sensory sensitivities, our guide to child meltdowns and what actually helps explains how meltdowns differ from behavior problems. Demand avoidance, covered in the parent's guide linked above, is another pattern a clinician can help you consider.
In our clinical experience, it is worth getting an evaluation before, or alongside, a parenting approach when outbursts happen at school as well as at home, when they appeared suddenly, when your child seems persistently irritable or sad between outbursts, or when sleep, eating, or school attendance have changed. We offer psychological assessments for teens aged 12 to 17 and adults. For younger children, a pediatrician or child psychologist is the right starting point.
When safety has to come first
Collaborative problem solving is a proactive approach for calm moments. It is not a crisis plan. In the middle of a dangerous outburst, the priority is keeping everyone safe, not solving the problem. If anyone is in immediate danger, call 911. If your child talks about suicide or about wanting to die, call or text 988, or call 911 in an emergency [11][12]. 988 also supports parents who are worried about a child in a mental health crisis [12]. If outbursts have ever involved threats or self-harm, lock up firearms, medications, and other dangerous items now, before the next one. Once things are calm, a clinician can help you build a safety plan for the next time.
🛟 Key takeaway: Plan B is for calm moments. When behavior is dangerous or comes with signs of a deeper problem, safety and an evaluation come first.
Next step: getting support
Explosive behavior is exhausting, and it is easy to feel you have tried everything. The research offers some real hope: family-based approaches like Collaborative & Proactive Solutions and parent management training each helped about half of children with oppositional defiant disorder in trials, and the gains held at six months [5][6]. Our therapists work with parents and families, including with parent management training, and you can meet our team to see who might be a good fit. If you are not sure what is driving your child's outbursts, keep a simple log for two weeks: when each outburst happened, what came just before it, and how long it lasted. Bring it to your child's pediatrician or evaluator. Parenting an explosive child is also stressful in its own right. If you are wondering how you are holding up, our mental health screening page has brief self-report screeners for adults, including for depression and anxiety.
🌱 Key takeaway: You do not have to choose between being firm and being kind. Collaborative approaches ask for both, one problem at a time.
Working through explosive moments at home?
Our therapists work with parents and families, including through parent management training, and we offer psychological assessments for teens aged 12 to 17. Talk with us about whether we are the right fit for your family.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is collaborative problem solving the same as gentle parenting?
Not exactly. Collaborative problem solving, as tested in the trials, is a structured model with specific steps, and it is not permissive: in a Plan B conversation the adult states their own concern and the plan has to work for both of you. The model also names Plan A (the adult decides alone) and Plan C (setting a problem aside for now), but its emphasis is on solving problems together. Gentle parenting is a broader label without one agreed method.
Does collaborative problem solving work for kids with ADHD or autism?
It may help, but the evidence for those groups is thinner. The main trials enrolled children with oppositional defiant disorder, some of whom also had ADHD or anxiety, and the large U.S. trial excluded autistic children. A Swedish trial of a modified, newer approach, in which children and parents work out solutions together, included many children with autism and ADHD and found more improvement than usual care over 10 weeks.
How long does collaborative problem solving take to make a difference?
Usually weeks to a few months, not days. In a large community trial, families had up to 16 weekly sessions, and the improvements held six months later. A clearinghouse summary of the program describes weekly hour-long sessions over about 7 to 16 weeks.
Can I learn collaborative problem solving on my own from a book?
Free materials on the model are available online, and reading them can be a reasonable first step. The research, though, tested versions guided by a trained clinician over several weeks, so it does not tell us how well self-teaching works. If outbursts are frequent, intense, or unsafe, working with a clinician is the better place to start.
Is Ross Greene's model the same as Think:Kids Collaborative Problem Solving?
They share roots but are now separate programs. The model Dr. Ross Greene studied, once called collaborative problem solving, is now called Collaborative & Proactive Solutions. Think:Kids, a program at Massachusetts General Hospital directed by Dr. Stuart Ablon, uses the name Collaborative Problem Solving. The U.S. and Australian trials in this article tested Collaborative & Proactive Solutions; the 2004 trial, led by Dr. Greene with Dr. Ablon as a co-author, tested the approach under its earlier name, and the Swedish trial tested a separate, modified model.
About the Author
Dr. Kiesa Kelly is a licensed clinical psychologist and the founder of ScienceWorks Behavioral Healthcare, with more than 20 years of experience in psychological assessment and evidence-based treatment. Her clinical work centers on ADHD, autism, obsessive-compulsive spectrum disorders, anxiety, and trauma, including sorting out what is driving a young person's behavior before choosing a treatment approach.
She earned her PhD in Clinical Psychology with a concentration in Neuropsychology from Rosalind Franklin University of Medicine and Science, and completed practica, internship, and an NIH-funded postdoctoral fellowship focused on ADHD at the University of Chicago, the University of Wisconsin, the University of Florida, and Vanderbilt University. Dr. Kelly is a psychologist, not a physician, and does not prescribe medication.
References
1. Greene R, Winkler J. Collaborative & Proactive Solutions (CPS): a review of research findings in families, schools, and treatment facilities. Clin Child Fam Psychol Rev. 2019;22(4):549-561. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10567-019-00295-z
2. California Evidence-Based Clearinghouse for Child Welfare. Collaborative & Proactive Solutions. https://www.cebc4cw.org/program/collaborative-proactive-solutions/
3. Lives in the Balance. Parents and families tour: learn the basics of Collaborative and Proactive Solutions. https://livesinthebalance.org/parents-and-families-tour/
4. Greene RW, Ablon JS, Goring JC, Raezer-Blakely L, Markey J, Monuteaux MC, et al. Effectiveness of collaborative problem solving in affectively dysregulated children with oppositional-defiant disorder: initial findings. J Consult Clin Psychol. 2004;72(6):1157-1164. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-006X.72.6.1157
5. Ollendick TH, Greene RW, Austin KE, Fraire MG, Halldorsdottir T, Allen KB, et al. Parent management training and Collaborative & Proactive Solutions: a randomized control trial for oppositional youth. J Clin Child Adolesc Psychol. 2016;45(5):591-604. https://doi.org/10.1080/15374416.2015.1004681
6. Murrihy RC, Drysdale SAO, Dedousis-Wallace A, Rémond L, McAloon J, Ellis DM, et al. Community-delivered Collaborative and Proactive Solutions and parent management training for oppositional youth: a randomized trial. Behav Ther. 2023;54(2):400-417. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.beth.2022.10.005
7. Lives in the Balance. What's the difference between CPS and other models? https://livesinthebalance.org/advocacy/whats-the-difference/
8. Think:Kids, Massachusetts General Hospital. About us. https://thinkkids.org/about/
9. National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. Antisocial behaviour and conduct disorders in children and young people: recognition and management (CG158). Published 2013, last updated 2017. https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/cg158/chapter/Recommendations
10. Johnson M, Gillberg C, Vinsa I, Fransson G, Samuelsson L, Jakobsson K, et al. A randomized controlled trial of a new intervention in early symptomatic syndromes eliciting neurodevelopmental clinical examinations: PR-ESSENCE. Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 2023;32(1):63-74. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00787-021-01837-z
11. National Institute of Mental Health. Disruptive mood dysregulation disorder (DMDD). https://www.nimh.nih.gov/health/topics/disruptive-mood-dysregulation-disorder-dmdd
12. 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline. https://988lifeline.org/
Disclaimer
This article is for informational and educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional medical or mental health advice, diagnosis, or treatment. It does not describe a specific ScienceWorks treatment program, and only a qualified clinician can evaluate your child. If anyone is in immediate danger, call 911. If a child or adult is thinking about suicide, call or text 988, or call 911 in an emergency.

